AI & judgment
When knowledge gets cheaper, what becomes more valuable?
English adaptation of an earlier Chinese essay.
AI makes explanations, examples and first drafts easier to obtain. But access to an answer is different from knowing what to do with it. Knowledge is a raw material; value comes from how we use it.
I think four abilities become more important as that raw material gets cheaper, in this order.
1. Judgment
Choosing the right problem, deciding which evidence to trust and recognizing a weak answer still matter. More available information makes those choices more frequent, rather than making them disappear.
2. The ability to complete the loop
An idea needs to become an action, an action needs a result and that result needs feedback. Following this loop through turns a plausible answer into something useful.
3. Depth
Knowing a field well helps you see assumptions, failure modes and tradeoffs that a fluent explanation can hide. Depth gives you a basis for checking what AI suggests.
4. Breadth
Experience across fields helps you connect ideas and recognize where a method might apply. Those connections are most useful when they lead back to a concrete problem, supported by enough depth to act.
AI lowers the barrier to obtaining knowledge. Turning that knowledge into value still requires judgment, execution and understanding. That is where I want to invest my effort.